Blog

For the second straight night, the Phillies had an opportunity to close in on a playoff spot. And for the second straight night, the Phillies laid an egg instead.

A stagnant offense and yet another late bullpen collapse doomed them in a 5-1 loss to the Brewers on Thursday night. Milwaukee secured its 100th win of the season, setting a franchise record at the expense of the Phillies.

The magic number remains at 2.

The Phillies will enter their final series of the regular season against the American League-leading Tampa Bay Rays without having officially secured a playoff spot. But with three games left to play, they still control their own destiny.

“We’re in the driver’s seat, so we’ve got to win and take care of our business,” Bryce Harper said. “We can’t really worry about any other teams or what they’re doing, so just got to keep going.”

But just as pressing for the club is the health of second baseman Luis Arráez, who departed the game in the sixth inning with a sprained left ankle. Arráez twisted it trying to dodge the tag at first base, and was unable to put weight on his foot as he was helped off the field. The Phillies said X-rays were negative and that Arráez will be evaluated further.

“We’ll know more tomorrow. I know they’ll treat him tonight. See what happens,” said interim manager Don Mattingly. “See how he walks in tomorrow. … I’m hopeful that he can play. But we’ll see.”

Edmundo Sosa took over at third base Thursday, with Bryson Stott sliding back to second base. Mattingly said the team would consider all its infield options if Arráez is unable to play. That could include Sosa filling in, or reverting to their pre-trade deadline infield with Harper returning to first.

“I think it’s the next man up mentality,” Harper said. “Sosa has been great for us all year, so if he’s in the lineup, obviously he’s going to be our guy.”

Andrew Painter finished what figures to be his final start of the regular season on a strong note, holding the Brewers to one run over six innings. His changeup was electric, generating 10 whiffs and accounting for six of his eight strikeouts.

“I think I just put it in good spots,” Painter said of his changeup. “I kept the ball down, and the misses were down or arm side, so nothing really over the plate. That’s where the damage has been done in the past.”

The right-hander lowered his second-half ERA to 3.65, after putting up a 7.08 marker in the first half. It was an up-and-down season for him overall, as Painter found himself back in triple A in June after extended struggles with his fastball and his command.

But the rookie managed to rebound, and now figures to play a key part in the Phillies’ postseason plans — should they get there — even if those plans aren’t concrete yet.

“I know the bullpen’s a possibility,” Painter said. “Haven’t been told that 100% yet.”

Painter let the leadoff man aboard in every inning save for the first and sixth, but the only time it scored was the leadoff walk to Gary Sánchez in the second. Consecutive hits — a soft grounder to the mound followed by a line drive that just snuck fair — brought in a run, though Painter ended the inning with back-to-back strikeouts.

Mattingly thinks the adversity Painter faced with his early struggles, June demotion, mid-season changes to his mechanics, and then his return to the majors, made him a stronger pitcher. And Thursday, in a game with playoff-like stakes against a playoff-caliber lineup, he proved he could step up.

“Paint’s legit,” Mattingly said. “I think Philadelphia’s going to like this kid for a while.”

The Brewers used five different arms, but the Phillies couldn’t do much damage against any of them. They scored their only run in the third against lefty Shane Drohan. Kyle Schwarber ripped a double and came home on an opposite-field line drive single from Harper.

But after that, a Schwarber single in the seventh was the only Phillies hit. Bryson Stott drew a walk in the ninth, but they failed to advance him.

NL wild-card standings

window.addEventListener(“message”,function(a){if(void 0!==a.data[“datawrapper-height”]){var e=document.querySelectorAll(“iframe”);for(var t in a.data[“datawrapper-height”])for(var r,i=0;r=e[i];i++)if(r.contentWindow===a.source){var d=a.data[“datawrapper-height”][t]+”px”;r.style.height=d}}});

It wasn’t for lack of hard contact. Phillies hitters clocked exit velocities higher than 95 mph 13 different times, but only three of those fell for hits. The Brewers, on the other hand, hit eight balls harder than 95 mph, five of which were hits.

“At times this year, it feels like that’s happened to us quite a bit,” said Trea Turner, who had a 107.4-mph groundout. “Last night we lined out a few times. Today again. That’s I think the frustrating part, where it feels like you go up there and tell yourself you had a good at-bat, you did what you could, but then you want to change something to try to get a little bit more production.”

Reliever Alex McFarlane came up big in the seventh, continuing to prove himself in leverage spots. After walking the first two batters he faced, the righty rebounded to strike out the next three to keep the game tied at 1.

Catcher J.T. Realmuto helped him with the first one, using an automated ball-strike challenge to flip ball three to strike three. McFarlane then struck out consecutive lefties: Garrett Mitchell looking on a sinker and Brice Turang swinging on a four-seam.

“Mac took a little bit to get going, but after that he was really good,” Mattingly said. “Got in a little bit of trouble with the walks early, and then got out of it.”

The Brewers took the lead against José Alvarado in the eighth inning as he struggled to command his pitches. Alvarado allowed a leadoff walk and two singles before recording an out as Milwaukee jumped ahead, 2-1. He was lifted for Chase Shugart, departing to loud boos, and the right-hander gave up two base hits up the middle to pad Milwaukee’s lead.

On a somewhat chilly night in South Philly, Alvarado’s velocity was down a few ticks, averaging 96 mph when it has usually sat at 97.9 this season. The pitch only got one whiff.

“Alvy’s been really good,” Mattingly said when asked if the down velocity was a concern. “We didn’t go into the game feeling like anything was wrong with those guys.”

Jackson Chourio homered off Tim Mayza in the ninth for good measure.

Time is running out on the regular season, but the Phillies will have another chance Friday to cut the magic number with Cristopher Sánchez on the mound against Tampa Bay.

“We should be feeling some pressure,” Mattingly said. “I know I feel some pressure, but I mean, it’s that time of year, and you’re trying to win games.”

Just in case you thought the Phillies only lost a game Thursday night, there was Luis Arraez, unable to put weight on his left leg as he limped off the field.

And now, it’s unclear if he will play again this season.

Diagnosed with a sprained left ankle after landing on it awkwardly to avoid a tag at first base while legging out a grounder in the sixth inning, Arraez’s availability will hinge on how he responds to treatment. X-rays were negative, according to interim manager Don Mattingly.

“We’ll see more, we’ll know more [Friday],” Mattingly said after the Phillies’ latest attempt to clinch a wild card was foiled with a 5-1 loss to the Brewers. “We’ll see what happens, see how he walks in, or talk to him [Friday].”

Arraez was unavailable for comment.

Closing in on his fourth batting title with a National League-leading .310 average, Arraez is hitting .278 with a .309 on-base percentage for the Phillies since they traded for him at the Aug. 3 deadline. He has been the cleanup hitter in all 44 of his starts.

The Phillies rearranged three-quarters of their infield to accommodate Arraez at second base. If he’s unable to play in the last three regular-season games against the Rays and (maybe) beyond, they could shuffle everything again, possibly even moving Bryce Harper back to first base from right field.

“Yeah,” Harper said. “I’ll do anything.”

When Arraez left the game, the Phillies moved Bryson Stott back to second base, inserted Edmundo Sosa at third, and kept Alec Bohm at first base and Harper in right field. Mattingly mentioned that as one potential alignment.

“I think it’s just putting our full effort in as a lineup and saying it’s the next-man-up mentality,” Harper said. “Sosa’s been great for us all year. So, if he’s in the lineup, obviously he’s going to be our guy even in the short term.”

Another possibility includes Bryan De La Cruz in right field, Harper at first base, and Bohm at third. The Rays are scheduled to start three left-handed pitchers, which likely keeps lefty-hitting Brandon Marsh in the lineup.

In any case, the Phillies must generate more offense. Even with Arraez, they scored once in each of the last two games against the Brewers after scoring three runs in five consecutive games last week against the Nationals and Mets.

Trea Turner said it would be “rough” if the Phillies must play without Arraez.

“He’s kind of locked down that four hole for us and just keep the line moving,” Turner said. “Whether people are on or he’s leading off, it feels like he’s making us a lot better. And the defense has been really good, too. So, I think that’s going to be a little bit of a blow.”

Arraez was trying to beat out a grounder to shortstop when Cooper Pratt’s throw pulled Jake Bauers off the first base bag. As Arraez tried to dodge the tag, he appeared to twist his ankle and fell to the ground in pain.

In an equally cruel twist, Arraez was called out when the umpires said he ran out of the baseline. Mattingly contested that Arraez’s last step before passing Bauers was in the box attached to the baseline.

“So, no matter how far he moves, for me, he’s in the box,” Mattingly said. “Now, if I’m wrong on that, I’m wrong. But he’s still inside that box. … I’ve always felt like you can run in that box all day long and do whatever. So, yeah, I don’t get that one.”