CHICAGO — Nick Sirianni took it on the chin.
Down 13 points late in the third quarter, the Eagles faced fourth-and-1 on their own 49-yard line. Sirianni had his offense line up as if it would attempt the Tush Push with Jalen Hurts sneaking for the first down.
But it was a long yard, and the Bears weren’t fooled into jumping offside. The Eagles took a delay-of-game penalty and punted.
“As I look back at that, I probably should have went for it there,” Sirianni said. “Didn’t like that decision.”
It was one of many that backfired on the coach and his team in a dreadful 27-7 loss to the Chicago Bears on Monday night. Sirianni’s regrets were isolated to the game — from his fourth-down turtling to his sideline behavior — but it’s unclear how he felt about larger decisions that have affected this season’s Eagles.
It’s too early to make sweeping generalizations. But the first three games have suggested the following: the defense isn’t as good as many had expected, first-time offensive coordinator Sean Mannion isn’t yet the “mad genius” some had suggested, and general manager Howie Roseman’s roster has more holes than it has had in years.
And that may be why, in that moment, Sirianni didn’t roll the dice on fourth-and-1. He didn’t believe his offense could convert or his defense could hold if they didn’t. In 2025, it might have been the offense that held him back. In 2023, it was often the defense.
For the first time since maybe his first season, he may not have either side to lean on. And that’s a scary thought with the Los Angeles Rams coming to town Sunday and a trip to London to face the Jacksonville Jaguars the following week.
“I think we all have to own that loss right there,” Sirianni said. “I don’t think anybody coached well. I don’t think anyone played well. It was a true team loss, and when it’s a true team loss, I have to look at myself first.”
The Eagles are through the “easy” early part of their schedule. They eked by the dubious Washington Commanders and Tennessee Titans in the first two weeks, but they still won, and growing pains were always expected with Mannion’s new offense.
There were unexpected cracks in Vic Fangio’s defensive armor, though, or craters in areas that were thought to be mere crevices. The Bears, despite having to start 38-year-old third-string quarterback Case Keenum, exposed them.
It was hard not to compare the actual offensive wizardry of Chicago coach Ben Johnson to Mannion. Johnson was one step ahead of Fangio all night, just as he was a year ago. Maybe Johnson is just the veteran defensive coordinator’s kryptonite. And maybe he’s buoyed by one of the best offensive lines in the NFL.
But it used to be the Eagles that had enough O-line supremacy to win with a backup quarterback.
Speaking of backups, the offseason debacle at the No. 2 spot finally caught up to the Eagles. Andy Dalton gets a slight pass here. He was tossed into a tough spot having to jump in for Hurts, who left to have his head checked in the second quarter.
Yeah, Dalton threw a horrible pass on third down that was intercepted in the end zone. But maybe if he wasn’t splitting snaps all of training camp and the preseason with Tanner McKee, he would have had a few more repetitions on the particular play that Mannion called.
“I’ve had it a couple times,” Dalton said. “Obviously, gotten a lot of different looks, and for me, it’s something that I can learn from, especially on that play. I mean … safety just read my eyes and was in the right spot.”
Dalton has been in this role before, but he didn’t outright win the job over McKee. Keeping four quarterbacks on the roster never made sense and just seemed to be the Eagles’ unwillingness to admit they made a mistake in trading for the also-38-year-old.
It’s just one of several roster decisions that have already come back to haunt Roseman. He can’t invest heavily in every position, but he clearly didn’t do enough at safety after Reed Blankenship walked in free agency. Marcus Epps has been a liability and Andrew Mukuba isn’t yet capable enough to cover for his counterpart.
Linebacker Jihaad Campbell, a second-year starter like Mukuba, is struggling as well. It doesn’t help that the Eagles also let the currently better Nakobe Dean sign elsewhere this offseason.
And then there’s this year’s top rookies with wide receiver Makai Lemon still green and tight end Eli Stowers still on ice. First-year players should be given a grace period, but the Eagles didn’t do enough at their respective positions and it’s showing.
Ultimately, these are Roseman problems. Sirianni’s issues extend to how the Eagles execute, and right now they’re uncharacteristically undisciplined. They had three turnovers on offense and failed to take away the ball on defense. Overall, they’re minus-5 in turnover differential, a statistic Sirianni considers of the utmost importance.
The Eagles had 10 penalties vs. the Bears, with so many either bringing back a long gain or giving the Bears life on third or fourth down. While the Eagles failed to get Chicago to jump on fourth down, defensive tackle Moro Ojomo carelessly committed a neutral zone infraction on fourth-and-2 early in the fourth quarter.
Mukuba and cornerback Riq Woolen had third-down penalties in the red zone. Guard Tyler Steen’s holding penalty brought back a long Saquon Barkley run. The Eagles must have had double-digit missed tackles a week after whiffing on 12 in Tennessee.
Sirianni and his coaches weren’t any better than their players. Mannion’s call for a screen pass to receiver DeVonta Smith with 19 seconds left before the half and the Eagles out of timeouts nearly resulted in the clock running out.
“We had 19 seconds,” Sirianni said. “We had plenty of time to be able to either get it clocked or do what we did in that particular case.”
They had one second left and if it wasn’t for Hurts’ quick thinking to skip the spike and sneak into the end zone from the 1-yard line, Sirianni would have taken more than just a jab to the jaw.
Mannion is Sirianni’s hire. He’s a first-time play-caller who needs patience to grow into the job. But his scheme has been unremarkable. He was supposedly hired to bring more under-center play-action to the offense, but the Eagles have not run much of it, or when they do, not effectively.
Where’s the misdirection? The aggressiveness? The innovation?
There were some positives in the run game. Barkley rushed for 73 yards on 11 carries in the first half, but he gained just 9 yards on four carries after the break.
Hurts didn’t look like the fearless, pocket-savvy passer that he appeared to be in the first two games. He had moments in the first half but also missed short throws, held the ball too long, and threw a ghastly fourth-down interception to T.J. Edwards a few drives after the former Eagle nearly duped the quarterback into another pick.
Sirianni said he didn’t regret that fourth-and-5 decision that came at the Bears’ 46 just before the end of the third quarter. But it only made the other fourth-down call look that much worse.
“I think competitively, I’m always going to want to go for it,” Hurts said. “Always trust coach to make the right decision, given these situations.”
Tackle Lane Johnson suggested there was more at play than trying to draw the Bears offside.
“I don’t know if we didn’t pay attention to the clock,” he said. “There was a play, but I don’t think we’re all on the same play. I think there’s a lot of miscommunication.”
Sirianni’s Eagles have bounced back from worse. The season is a marathon. You’ve got to think Fangio corrects some of the defensive miscues. And the positive steps Hurts seemingly took in the first two weeks can’t be forgotten with just one shaky performance.
Change on offense was necessary, even if Kevin Patullo’s unit last season was never held under 10 points like Mannion’s was in just his third game as coordinator. But Sirianni remains the constant. Most of his teams have taken on his positive traits, if not one of the negatives.
He lost control of his emotions again after Hurts was decked by Bears linebacker D’Marco Jackson in the second quarter. It ended up being a fateful play, but the coach conceded that he went too far in yelling expletives at Jackson.
“I always love fighting for our players. I love our guys,” Sirianni said. “And so, the emotion of the game probably got the better of me today. And I have to learn from that in that particular moment. I have to be more steady in that situation.”
The Eagles, like their coach, got knocked off their axis at Soldier Field. The next few weeks could reveal if they have the resolve to get up after a shaky start.
